When Words Aren't Enough

There was a moment recently, maybe you’ve had one too, when I sat back after a long work call and realised something unsettling.
We were talking, aligning, sharing insights.
And yet beneath all the energy and intention, I felt it: a gap.
A disconnection between the values we spoke about, candour, inclusion, psychological safety, and the way those values were actually showing up in the everyday fabric of how we worked.

It’s not a gap born of bad intentions.
Most leaders I’ve worked with genuinely care.
They want to create spaces where people can think freely, speak openly, and belong fully.
But good intentions aren’t enough when the systems, behaviours, and daily interactions don't consistently match the words we say.

We are surrounded by powerful language.
Mission statements. Culture decks. Leadership promises.
But values that are spoken more than lived start to lose their meaning.
And when that happens, something vital quietly fractures, not just trust, but the deeper connection that makes leadership truly work.

In leadership, the space between what we declare and what we do isn’t just a communications problem.
It’s a human systems problem.
Because leadership isn’t measured in what we announce.
It’s measured in what people experience, and in what they feel safe enough to say back to us.

Saying one thing and doing another erodes more than just trust. It fractures the invisible system that holds teams together.

When leaders say one thing but do another, the damage runs deeper than broken promises.
It fractures the invisible systems that hold teams together, trust, safety, belonging, and belief.

Many organisations today promote values like candour, psychological safety, and human-centred leadership.
These are not trivial aspirations. They represent a genuine evolution in how we understand leadership and culture.
But when these values are not consistently practised, when critical voices are quietly sidelined, when inclusion is spoken but not lived, when challenge is invited but subtly punished, a different kind of erosion begins.

It is not just the erosion of productivity.
It is the erosion of courage.
Of connection.
Of the belief that leadership is worthy of trust.

Over time, this erosion doesn't just silence individuals.
It hollows out the culture itself.
It replaces real connection with cautious compliance.
It turns collaboration into calculation.

And by the time the effects are visible in performance metrics or engagement surveys, the real damage has already been done, quietly, daily, relationally.

In a world hungry for authentic leadership, the gap between words and actions is not a small crack.
It is a growing fault line.
And if leaders do not tend to it, the ground beneath them will shift.

Toolkit: The Leadership Mirror Exercise

True leadership change starts with self-awareness — and grows through shared conversation.
This two-part exercise helps close the gap between stated values and lived experience.

Part 1: Self-Reflection

Begin with yourself. Take a quiet moment to reflect on these questions:

• What behaviours would someone observe from me today that prove our values are real?

• Where might my behaviour unintentionally contradict the values I promote?

• What one action could I take this week to better embody the culture I want to create?

Use this reflection as a private check-in.
Notice without judgement.
Real connection starts with real honesty.

Part 2: Team Conversation

Then, invite your team into the reflection. Use these prompts to open a conversation about how your shared values show up day-to-day:

• Where do we see our values most alive in our work together?

• Where might there be a gap between what we say we value and what we actually practice?

• What small actions could we take, individually and collectively, to better live our values this quarter?

Approach the conversation with curiosity, not defensiveness.
The goal is not perfection.
The goal is connection, and the courage to align behaviour with belief.

Values are not cultural wallpaper.

They are behaviours, systems, and everyday moments of interaction.
They live (or die) in the small spaces between meetings, decisions, feedback, and recognition.

In organisational psychology, we call this the values-practice gap — the space between what organisations say they value, and what leaders and teams actually demonstrate day to day.

At first, the signs of that gap are subtle:

• People hesitate before speaking up.

• Feedback softens into something polite, but powerless.

• Innovation slows, but no one quite names it.

Over time, the effects deepen.

• Trust becomes conditional.

• Psychological safety thins out.

• Feedback withers into silence.

• Connection becomes transactional.

The culture is still functioning , technically, but it has shifted from connection to compliance.

Leadership is not about declaring values.
It is about embodying them consistently, especially when it’s uncomfortable, complex, or inconvenient.

At Beyond Work, we developed the Connected Leadership approach precisely to address this gap.
Not by adding more language around values — but by helping leaders build the habits, systems, and structures that make human-centred leadership real, sustainable, and scalable.

Because cultures are not shaped by what leaders announce.
They are shaped by what leaders repeat, reinforce, and reward — especially when no one is watching.

If we want real change, we have to start there:
In the daily patterns that either pull people into connection, or push them toward caution.

(Explore the Connected Leadership learning experience at Beyond Work.)

Measuring Leadership by Connection, Not Control

It is measured by the spaces we create, and by what people feel safe enough to share within them.

When connection is real, people will tell you the truth.
They will offer their ideas, their struggles, their doubts, and their hopes.
They will trust you with the raw material of change — if they believe you will hold it with care and courage.

As you lead, ask yourself:

1. Are people growing quieter around me?

2. Or braver?

True leadership is not about being admired from a distance.
It is about being trusted up close.

If you’d like to explore more about building connected, human-centred leadership, here are some resources you might find valuable:

• Radical Candor by Kim Scott — on balancing direct feedback with personal care.

• Fierce Conversations by Susan Scott — on building real relationships through courageous dialogue.

• Authentic Leadership by Bill George — on leading with integrity and relational transparency.

• Compassionate Leadership by Rasmus Hougaard and Jacqueline Carter — on balancing care and wisdom in leadership.

• Leadership Unmasked by Marut Bhardwaj — on rediscovering leadership through authenticity, connection, and courage.

• Connected Leadership — our Beyond Work learning experience for leading with humanity, accountability, and real connection.

• Mind the Gap: Why Good Intentions Aren't Enough in Leadership Culture

• Sage: The Beyond Work Companion — your AI partner for leadership reflection and culture change.

(Some book links may be affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission if you choose to purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.)

Curious to explore more?

Join the Beyond Work community for weekly reflections, practical tools, and leadership insights that help you build stronger, more human systems at work. Join the Beyond Work Community

PS: If this reflection resonated with you, I’d love if you shared it with a colleague who believes leadership should be more human too.

Upcoming Workshop